• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Paleo Leap
  • Recipes
    • Beef and Red Meat
    • Chicken and Poultry
    • Pork
    • Fish and Seafood
    • Eggs
    • Soups
    • Salads
    • Sides, Veggies and Appetizers
    • Sauces, Dips & Vinaigrettes
    • Drinks
    • Sweets and Snacks
    • Cooking Tips
  • Learn
  • Your Starting Point
    • Topic Index
    • Paleo 101
    • Paleo Meal Plan
    • Paleo Food List
    • Transitioning to Paleo
    • Am I Doing it Right? - Checklist
    • Mini-Course for Beginners
  • Popular Topics
    • Recipes for Beginners
    • Breakfast Ideas
    • Homemade Condiments
    • Legumes
    • Wheat & Gluten
    • Dairy
    • Nightshades
  • More
    • Compilations
    • Foods
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • Chicken
  • Pork
  • Snacks
  • Salads
  • Learn Paleo
  • Paleo Cooking Tips
  • Paleo Diet Foods
  • Paleo Recipe Compilations
  • Keto Diet Recipes
  • Paleo Beef and Red Meat Recipes
  • Paleo Drink Recipes
  • Paleo Egg Recipes
  • Paleo Fish and Seafood Recipes
  • Paleo Sauces and Dips
  • Paleo Sides, Veggies and Appetizers
  • Paleo Soup Recipes
  • Paleo Tips & Tricks
  • Paleo Topic Index
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • search icon
    Homepage link
    • Recipes
    • Chicken
    • Pork
    • Snacks
    • Salads
    • Learn Paleo
    • Paleo Cooking Tips
    • Paleo Diet Foods
    • Paleo Recipe Compilations
    • Keto Diet Recipes
    • Paleo Beef and Red Meat Recipes
    • Paleo Drink Recipes
    • Paleo Egg Recipes
    • Paleo Fish and Seafood Recipes
    • Paleo Sauces and Dips
    • Paleo Sides, Veggies and Appetizers
    • Paleo Soup Recipes
    • Paleo Tips & Tricks
    • Paleo Topic Index
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • ร—
    Home ยป Learn About Paleo & Keto Diets

    In Defense of Animal Protein

    Last Modified: Feb 8, 2023 by Paleo Leaper ยท This post may contain affiliate links ยท Leave a Comment

    Sharing is caring!

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Reddit

    Paleo is heavy on the defense of animal fat: lard, butter, duck fat, and tallow are all Paleo-friendly traditional fats that make your food delicious as well as providing plenty of healthy fuel. But what about a closely-related target, animal protein?

    Plenty of vegan groups like to claim that animal protein causes colon cancer (and/or obesity, heart disease, diabetes, kidney failure, early deathโ€ฆyou name it, PETA thinks eating animals causes it.) But does that really hold up under scrutiny? Actually, if you look at the evidence from scientific studies instead of vegan blogs, the relationships between animal protein and chronic diseases start to look pretty tenuous.

    Want the details? Here you go!

    The Problem with Epidemiological Research

    Proponents of vegan or vegetarian diets like to point to studies showing that intake of protein from animal foods is associated with colorectal cancer or various other diseases. This is called epidemiological research, and itโ€™s interesting, but all it shows is association. Association doesnโ€™t prove anything about causation. Just because two things happen at the same time doesnโ€™t mean one caused the other. Burglary and ice cream sales both increase in the summer, but that doesnโ€™t mean that eating ice cream causes burglary, or that burglary causes people to crave ice cream.

    Just a few problems to consider with research finding associations between animal protein and diseases:

    • It canโ€™t separate animal protein from everything else found in animal foods (like, say, animal fat, which is an entirely different question and shouldnโ€™t be confused with animal protein if weโ€™re trying to look at protein specifically). For example, this study found that dairy protein and dairy calcium were independently associated with a higher risk of prostate cancer. So does calcium cause cancer now too? Or is there something else in dairy foods? Would the effect hold for pastured dairy? Fermented dairy? Unprocessed dairy in general and not yogurts packed with sugar?
    bad food
    Is this meal really unhealthy because of the animal protein in the burger?
    • It canโ€™t separate animal foods from all the other diet patterns they go along with. Anything โ€œassociated withโ€ hamburgers is also associated with hamburger buns, and probably also with the huge jugs of sugary drinks most people have alongside their burgers. This study really takes the cake: it looked at colon cancer and compared low-risk Native Africans eating a diet high in resistant starch to high-risk Americans, and found that the Americans had different bacterial fermentation byproducts in their colons. Because obviously the only difference between Africans on a traditional diet and Americans eating an industrial diet is animal protein.
    • It doesnโ€™t account for the healthy user bias. Since weโ€™ve all been warned off animal protein for so long, the type of person who eats a lot of it is likely the type of person who doesnโ€™t care much about health in general. You can adjust the analysis for certain factors like smoking or exercise, but thereโ€™s no accurate way to adjust for โ€œjust not giving a hoot.โ€
    • Dietary measurement isnโ€™t accurate. A lot of epidemiological research relies on food-frequency questionnaires or other extremely inaccurate estimates of what and how much people actually eat. Everyone underestimates โ€œbadโ€ foods (like, say, animal protein), and everyone overestimates โ€œgoodโ€ foods. If your data on peopleโ€™s dietary habits is largely imaginary, how can you possibly draw useful conclusions about what diet patterns are associated with what diseases?

    All of those are reasons to be skeptical about claims that animal protein โ€œcausesโ€ anything. Pay close attention to the wording in the actual studies (as opposed to the newspaper headlines): โ€œassociated withโ€ does NOT mean โ€œcausesโ€!

    Evidence in Favor of Animal Protein

    Whatโ€™s more, thereโ€™s plenty of epidemiological research that shows no association between animal protein and cancer (or other diseases), and even some suggesting it may be beneficial.

    Evidence About Cancer

    Since cancer is one of the most common diseases that animal protein is supposed to โ€œcause,โ€ itโ€™s worth a closer look. Some studies have found an association (remember: this is not proof of causation!) between animal protein and cancer, but others have found the opposite. For example, this study found no significant effect of total protein, animal protein, red meat, processed meat, poultry, and/or seafood on risk of renal cell cancer.

    Other studies have strange and inconclusive results. This one, just for example, found that protein intake was associated with a higher risk of cancer until age 65, with a very slight bump in cancer risk from animal protein specifically. But after age 65, protein was associated with a lower risk. The authorsโ€™ explanation for this was a hormone called IGF-1, but the evidence for this is pretty shaky. Zoe Harcombe did a great job taking down the supposed โ€œproofโ€ in this study that protein caused cancer, diabetes, or anything else, and here is a great and very in-depth breakdown of why IGF-1 (the supposed link between animal protein and cancer in that study) doesnโ€™t actually work like that.

    A meta-analysis in 2009 found that: โ€œthe available epidemiologic evidence does not appear to support an independent association between animal fat intake or animal protein intake and colorectal cancer.โ€ This 2013 review found โ€œno statistically significant associations between total protein intake or LCHP [low-carb, high-protein] diets and cancer mortalityโ€ฆand the only study that also included protein sources found non-significant relations to animal- and vegetable-based protein.โ€

    In other words, the association between animal protein and cancer isnโ€™t even clear, and the only real explanation (IGF-1) isnโ€™t very convincing.

    Evidence About Diabetes

    OK, so what about animal protein causing diabetes? A higher intake of animal protein is associated with a higher risk of diabetes in several studies, but again, associations and causes are two different things.

    This study controlled for some of the potential confounding factors by feeding people with Type 2 Diabetes two different types of meals for 6 weeks:

    • Group A got meals with 60% animal protein and 40% plant protein.
    • Group B got meals with 100% plant protein.

    At the end of the studyโ€ฆ

    โ€œThere were no significant differences between diets for glomerular filtration rate, renal plasma flow, albumin excretion rate, total cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, triglyceride area under the curve (AUC), glucose and insulin AUC, HbA(1c,) blood pressure, or serum amino acids. For both diets, at the end of the treatment periods as compared with baseline, total cholesterol was significantly lowerโ€ฆHbA(1c) had significantly improved โ€ฆand diastolic blood pressure was significantly lower.โ€

    The study showed no advantage of a 100% plant-based diet compared to a diet containing animal protein.

    Other Diseases

    Next up is a grab-bag: a few other diseases where even the epidemiological research agrees that thereโ€™s no real role for animal protein.

    animal protein
    • This study found that both plant and animal protein were associated with lower blood pressure.
    • This meta-analysis found a moderately beneficial effect of total protein on blood pressure in some studies, with no special relationship for either plant or animal protein.
    • This study found that animal protein was not associated with kidney stone formation. A diet low in overall protein may be helpful for people with existing stones, but that doesnโ€™t prove anything about animal protein specifically.

    Animal protein: not actually such a demon nutrient. Really.

    Summing it Up

    With all due respect to the vegans, thereโ€™s just no evidence that animal protein per se causes anything bad. Thereโ€™s some epidemiological evidence that itโ€™s associated with higher rates of certain problems, but thereโ€™s also a lot of epidemiological evidence showing that itโ€™s not actually associated with those exact same problems, and in any case, association proves nothing about causation.

    The chronic problem of separating โ€œanimal proteinโ€ from animal foods in general begs the question of why you would care about separating โ€œanimal proteinโ€ from whole foods like steak, considering that almost nobody eats animal protein except in the context of an actual food. Thatโ€™s a great question โ€“ ask the people who keep accusing โ€œanimal proteinโ€ specifically of causing so many horrible diseases. Maybe once we get past the fixation on โ€œanimal proteinโ€ as the cause of everything wrong in the world, we can do some more interesting studies on overall lifestyle patterns โ€“ like comparing a Paleo-style diet rich in red meat to a Standard American diet with the same amount of red meat, to see whether the supposed health risks still hold up. Now that would be some interesting research!

    More Learn About Paleo & Keto Diets

    • closeup of a white bowl filled with Garlic & Roasted Onion Salsa
      Garlic & Roasted Onion Salsa
    • plate filled with blackened tilapia and sliced lemon
      Blackened Tilapia
    • Crab Stuffed Salmon served on a cutting board
      Crab Stuffed Salmon
    • 17 paleo bars & bites to snack on featured
      17 Paleo Bars & Bites To Snack On

    Sharing is caring!

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Reddit

    Filed Under: Learn About Paleo & Keto Diets

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    Primary Sidebar

    paleo leap square logo

    Hi, I'm Rick! Paleo Leap is the oldest and biggest resource online, covering everything about the paleo diet. We have over 1500 recipes categorized and plenty of meal plans for you to try.

    More about me โ†’

    Popular

    • Bacon-Wrapped Salmon Featured
      Bacon-Wrapped Salmon Recipe
    • Almond Milk Custard
      Almond Milk Custard Recipe
    • Flourless Banana Pancakes Featured
      Flourless Banana Pancakes Recipe
    • Turban Squash Soup Featured
      Turban Squash Soup Recipe

    Recent Recipes:

    • closeup of a glass of Almond banana cinnamon smoothie on a wood table
      Almond Banana Cinnamon Smoothie
    • glass of Peach and chocolate green smoothie on a wood table with peaches in the background
      Peach and Chocolate Green Smoothie
    • closeup of two glasses of cinnamon and Coconut vanilla milkshake
      Coconut Vanilla Milkshake
    • Pumpkin smoothie in a glass on a wood table with cinnamon sticks in the background
      Pumpkin Smoothie

    Footer

    โ†‘ back to top

    About

    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Cookie Policy

    Newsletter

    • Sign Up! for emails and updates

    Contact

    • Contact

    As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

    For your information only. The statements on this website are merely opinions. Paleo Leap does not provide medical or nutritional advice, treatment, or diagnosis. Read the full disclaimer.

    Copyright ยฉ 2023 Paleo Leap