• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Paleo Leap
  • Recipes
    • Beef and Red Meat
    • Chicken and Poultry
    • Pork
    • Fish and Seafood
    • Eggs
    • Soups
    • Salads
    • Sides, Veggies and Appetizers
    • Sauces, Dips & Vinaigrettes
    • Drinks
    • Sweets and Snacks
    • Cooking Tips
  • Learn
  • Your Starting Point
    • Topic Index
    • Paleo 101
    • Paleo Meal Plan
    • Paleo Food List
    • Transitioning to Paleo
    • Am I Doing it Right? - Checklist
    • Mini-Course for Beginners
  • Popular Topics
    • Recipes for Beginners
    • Breakfast Ideas
    • Homemade Condiments
    • Legumes
    • Wheat & Gluten
    • Dairy
    • Nightshades
  • More
    • Compilations
    • Foods
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • Chicken
  • Pork
  • Snacks
  • Salads
  • Learn Paleo
  • Paleo Cooking Tips
  • Paleo Diet Foods
  • Paleo Recipe Compilations
  • Keto Diet Recipes
  • Paleo Beef and Red Meat Recipes
  • Paleo Drink Recipes
  • Paleo Egg Recipes
  • Paleo Fish and Seafood Recipes
  • Paleo Sauces and Dips
  • Paleo Sides, Veggies and Appetizers
  • Paleo Soup Recipes
  • Paleo Tips & Tricks
  • Paleo Topic Index
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • search icon
    Homepage link
    • Recipes
    • Chicken
    • Pork
    • Snacks
    • Salads
    • Learn Paleo
    • Paleo Cooking Tips
    • Paleo Diet Foods
    • Paleo Recipe Compilations
    • Keto Diet Recipes
    • Paleo Beef and Red Meat Recipes
    • Paleo Drink Recipes
    • Paleo Egg Recipes
    • Paleo Fish and Seafood Recipes
    • Paleo Sauces and Dips
    • Paleo Sides, Veggies and Appetizers
    • Paleo Soup Recipes
    • Paleo Tips & Tricks
    • Paleo Topic Index
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • ร—
    Home ยป Learn About Paleo & Keto Diets

    Is Paleo a Fad Diet?

    Last Modified: Jan 26, 2023 by Paleo Leaper ยท This post may contain affiliate links ยท Leave a Comment

    Sharing is caring!

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Reddit

    As nice as it is to see Paleo getting increasing amounts of press in mainstream news media, itโ€™s incredibly frustrating that the publicity always has to come along with the constant description of โ€œa fad diet called Paleo.โ€ Itโ€™s easy to understand why people do this (dismissing Paleo as a โ€œfadโ€ gives them a justification for continuing their familiar, unhealthy eating habits without feeling guilty), but itโ€™s always frustrating, and itโ€™s completely inaccurate. In reality, Paleo is different from โ€œfad dietsโ€ in several very significant ways.

    is paleo a fad diet main

    Characteristics of Fad Diets

    In general, fad diets are short-term weight-loss plans that rely special tricks and gimmicks to disguise how they really work: an extreme reduction in calorie intake. They play on the psychological rollercoaster of self-hatred and desire for immediate results, and ride that wave of short-term motivation until the dieter caves and goes off the diet, and then blames herself for โ€œhaving no willpowerโ€ or โ€œbeing lazy.โ€ Take a look at some common characteristics of a fad diet:

    • Clearly designed for the short term: unsustainable restriction of calories or food choices (e.g. the 2-4-6-8 diet, where you eat 200 calories the first day, then 400, then 600, then 800, and then cycle back to 200 and start over).
    • Obsessive focus on one food as a demon or a cure-all (e.g. the grapefruit diet, where grapefruit is supposedly the holy grail of all foods)
    • Designed for weight loss, not health, e.g. the HcG diet, which uses dangerous hormone injections to stave off hunger at 500 calories per day.
    • Promises about โ€œeffortlessโ€ weight loss, miraculous benefits, or other claims that are just too good to be true (e.g. Aoqili diet soap, which promises to somehow reduce the fat molecules under your skin while you shower, no food restriction required)
    • One strict set of rules about what to do (e.g. the Sacred Heart Diet, which lays out an entire meal plan of constantly shifting food restrictions for different days)

    Some dietitians also define a โ€œfad dietโ€ as โ€œanything that doesnโ€™t meet the USDA Dietary Guidelines,โ€ but this is just knee-jerk defensiveness: thereโ€™s nothing infallible about the USDA, and whatever legitimate criticisms you can make about fad diets, โ€œit isnโ€™t profitable for the dairy industryโ€ is not one of them. So ignoring the nonissue that Paleo doesnโ€™t comply with USDA guidelines, does it meet the other criteria for fad diets listed above?

    Short-Term Mindset

    Fad diets arenโ€™t sustainable โ€“ most of them are so unbearably restrictive that youโ€™d have to be missing your taste buds to even consider sticking with them for the long haul. For example, take a look at the baby food diet, which involves replacing 2 meals a day with up to 14 jars of baby food. The idea is that not only is baby food low in calories, but itโ€™s also free of additives and preservatives, full of nutrients, and prepackaged in easily portion-controlled jars.

    All this sounds great, but who in their right mind would want to eat baby food for 2 meals every day for any length of time? Itโ€™s bland. Itโ€™s mushy. Itโ€™s probably not even all that appetizing to babies, but they canโ€™t complain about it. Almost nobody would be able to stick to this diet for more than a week or two at the most; itโ€™s just too boring and monotonous.

    Itโ€™s also unsustainable because baby food doesnโ€™t provide all the nutrients an adult needs, notably sodium, calcium, and fat, not to mention adequate calories. Eating the baby food diet in the long term would actually be dangerous to your health.

    Thatโ€™s why most of these diets are actually packaged as quick weight-loss plans that are only supposed to last for a few weeks at most. Theyโ€™re not designed for lifelong adherence. Unfortunately, this means that the weight loss is as temporary as the restriction. The dramatic decrease at the beginning is really nothing but water weight, which dieters regain immediately when they start eating regular food again โ€“ as they certainly will.

    Contrast that with Paleo, which is designed for comfortable and healthy long-term maintenance. Unlike fad diets, Paleo helps you develop a healthy mindset about food, and learn how to navigate realistic compromises between the chocolate cake all around you and the desire to take care of your body. Itโ€™s not all-out for a week and then back to โ€œnormalโ€ with a sigh of relief and a shudder every time you pass the baby food aisle; itโ€™s nutritionally complete, healthy, and workable for the long term.

    Obsessive Focus on One Food

    A related trend in fad diets is a fixation on the supposed health benefits or dangers of just one type of food. For example, take the grapefruit diet, which promises to help you lose 10 pounds in 12 days by eating ยฝ a grapefruit before every meal. Some of the health claims on the website (with poor spelling and grammar preserved from the original) include:

    โ€œCitric acid of fresh grapefruit juice has an alkaline reaction that increase the alkalinity in the body. The fruit juice has been found useful in treating many diseases caused by too much acid in the body system.โ€

    Weโ€™ve debunked this myth extensively here. The only way to get โ€œtoo much acid in the body systemโ€ is to inject it into your bloodstream, in which case youโ€™d be beyond the power of grapefruit to help.

    โ€œGrapefruit stimulates appetite and posses unique ability to burn away fat, for many years people have used the fruit to lose weight.โ€

    It makes you hungrier, and this is supposed to be useful for dieters? The website is also very light on the evidence for the โ€œunique ability to burn away fat.

    โ€œGrapefruit peel is rich with pectin which is used for the preservation of other fruits. The peel oil can also be use as soft-drink flavouring.โ€

    Considering that nobody eats the peel, itโ€™s not clear why this matters. In fact, even if you did eat the peel, itโ€™s not clear how this would be relevant unless you plan to set up a soft-drink flavoring factory in your stomach and need some raw materials.

    โ€œGrapefruit contain natural โ€˜quinineโ€™ which is used to treat malaria. This โ€˜quinineโ€™ can be extracted by boiling a quarter of a grapefruit and straining the pulp.โ€

    If you have malaria, go see a doctor who can give you some actual quinine that will actually cure your disease. If you donโ€™t have malaria but do want to lose weight, thereโ€™s no evidence that quinine will do anything to help.

    Grapefruit juice inhibits a special enzyme in the intestines that is responsible for the natural breakdown and absorption of many medications.

    Making medications less effective is supposed to be a benefit?

    There are no references cited for any of these claims. Contrast this with any Paleo site, even the personal blogs run by non-experts. Yes, we love certain foods for their health benefits, but no single food is held up as the shining example of nutritional perfection. Even vegetables arenโ€™t safe from criticism! You can eat Paleo without ever touching a drop of coconut oil or a single leaf of kale. Because itโ€™s not fixated on any one particular food, Paleo represents a much more balanced spectrum of nutrition.

    Weight Loss Above All

    Why does anyone go on a fad diet? Itโ€™s not because they really think theyโ€™ll be healthier eating only cabbage soup or baby food; itโ€™s because theyโ€™re desperate to lose weight at all costs, even if that cost is their long-term health. In other words, creators of these diets start with the question, โ€œwhat will cause the fastest weight loss?โ€ and not โ€œwhat will make people healthiest?โ€

    The result is extreme plans like the hCG diet, a regimen that claims to banish 30 pounds in a month using a combination of an extremely low-calorie diet (500 calories per day) and special hormone injections made from pregnant womenโ€™s urine. Obviously, this is a seriously malnourishing diet, because itโ€™s just not possible for an adult human to meet all their micronutrient needs with that calorie intake.

    Paleo is the complete opposite of these diets, because it starts with the question of what human beings will be healthiest eating. The goal is health first and foremost โ€“ for some people, it means weight loss; for others, it means weight maintenance, and for others, it might even mean weight gain. Since itโ€™s about real health and not just dropping pounds, Paleo doesnโ€™t carry the dangerous consequences of untested โ€œmiracle therapiesโ€ or the risks of nutrient deficiencies. Itโ€™s appropriate for everyone, unlike fad diets that are only targeted towards overweight people in the first place.

    Promises about โ€œEffortlessโ€ Weight Loss

    To go along with these absurdly extreme prescriptions, fad diets tend to make ridiculous claims about their effects. For example, take this claim from a website promoting the Master Cleanse (a crash diet based on consuming nothing but a lemon juice/maple syrup/cayenne pepper โ€œlemonadeโ€ for 10 days straight):

    As a reducing diet it is superior in every way, reducing at a rate of about two pounds a day for most persons, without harmful side effects...Those with chronic illnesses have the potential for tremendous benefit as Mr Burroughs proved repeatedly over 35 years that toxicity is the cause of ALL illness.

    The rapid weight loss of 2 pounds a day might actually be true โ€“ but itโ€™s all water weight and muscle wasting. Muscle wasting is dangerous and unhealthy, and water weight will come right back when you start eating food again, so the โ€œweight lossโ€ is just an illusion. And the implication that a โ€œcleanseโ€ of lemon juice, cayenne pepper, and maple syrup can heal โ€œthe cause of ALL illnessโ€ is ridiculous.

    Paleo is a very effective diet for weight loss, but youโ€™d be hard-pressed to find this kind of hyperbole. Just to give one quote from the Perfect Health Diet book:

    โ€œAt an expenditure of 3,162 calories per day and consumption of 2,481 calories per day, fat loss would be about 75 grams per day, 1.2 pounds per week, 60 pounds per year.โ€ (p. 390)

    Note the focus on the long term, the realistic and achievable calorie deficit, and the โ€œslow and steadyโ€ rate of weight loss that doesnโ€™t rely on rapidly shedding water weight in the first few days.

    Paleo is also very effective for treating illness, especially chronic illnesses, but it resists the temptation to make unsupportable health claims, least of all the claim that an unmodified, generic Paleo template will magically heal every conceivable illness. While a Paleo approach isa good starting point for treating chronic disease, everyone agrees that diseases are more complicated than โ€œjust eat Paleo and youโ€™ll magically be cured.โ€

    One Strict Set of Rules

    Most fad diets have a single plan that you have to follow โ€“ otherwise, youโ€™ve failed at sticking to it. For example, take the Sacred Heart Diet. Itโ€™s based around a special cabbage soup, and the 7-day plan looks like this:

    • Day 1: soup and fruit (except bananas)
    • Day 2: soup and vegetables, with a baked potato at dinner, but no fruit
    • Day 3: soup, fruit, and vegetables, but no potato
    • Day 4: soup, bananas, and skim milk, but no fruits, vegetables, or potatoes
    • Day 5: soup, some beef, and up to 6 tomatoes
    • Day 6: soup, beef, and vegetables, but no potato
    • Day 7: soup, brown rice, fruit juice, and vegetables

    This is supposed to somehow take advantage of the combinations of different foods to help you lose weight faster. As you can see, the rules are basically handed down from above without allowing the dieters themselves any flexibility in the plan. (Also note that this diet shows several of the other characteristics above, most notably the focus on one single food).

    Contrast that to Paleo, where the โ€œdietโ€ is a set of principles for thinking about foods, not a strict list of โ€œallowedโ€ and โ€œforbiddenโ€ foods or worse yet, a required menu. This means that it relies on individuals to interpret the principles and intelligently apply them to their specific circumstances, not just mindlessly follow along with a set of daily menus. Yes, there are meal plans available, but these are mostly for convenience, not because they represent the only way around to eat Paleo.

    Conclusion

    Clearly, Paleo is very different from the typical โ€œfad diets.โ€ Paleo has a healthy and sustainable variety of foods; fad diets are extremely focused on one โ€œmiracleโ€ food or so restrictive nobody can stay on them for long. Paleo has an organic, grass-roots group of people searching for the optimal way for human beings to eat; fad diets have a fixed set of rules handed down from some authority figure and are only concerned with weight loss.

    In the end, the term โ€œPaleoโ€ and the caveman imagery might make the ancestral health movement look like a fad diet. If you try to imagine the โ€œcaveman fad diet,โ€ you might think of things like raw meat (unsustainable and restrictive), an arbitrary set of rules (โ€œthis is what cavemen didโ€) and a crazy culture of lunatic fans. But that caricature isnโ€™t actually what Paleo is like โ€“ if the real Paleo diet is a fad, itโ€™s a fad that lasted 10,000 years before temporarily getting derailed by the advent of agriculture.

    The caveman image might serve its usefulness and fade away, but the idea of Paleo is definitely not a fad โ€“ itโ€™s slowly but surely challenging misguided recommendations about grains, salt, saturated fat, and cholesterol, and in one form or another, itโ€™s here to stay.

    More Learn About Paleo & Keto Diets

    • closeup of a white bowl filled with Garlic & Roasted Onion Salsa
      Garlic & Roasted Onion Salsa
    • plate filled with blackened tilapia and sliced lemon
      Blackened Tilapia
    • Crab Stuffed Salmon served on a cutting board
      Crab Stuffed Salmon
    • 17 paleo bars & bites to snack on featured
      17 Paleo Bars & Bites To Snack On

    Sharing is caring!

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Reddit

    Filed Under: Learn About Paleo & Keto Diets

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    Primary Sidebar

    paleo leap square logo

    Hi, I'm Rick! Paleo Leap is the oldest and biggest resource online, covering everything about the paleo diet. We have over 1500 recipes categorized and plenty of meal plans for you to try.

    More about me โ†’

    Popular

    • Bacon-Wrapped Salmon Featured
      Bacon-Wrapped Salmon Recipe
    • Almond Milk Custard
      Almond Milk Custard Recipe
    • Flourless Banana Pancakes Featured
      Flourless Banana Pancakes Recipe
    • Turban Squash Soup Featured
      Turban Squash Soup Recipe

    Recent Recipes:

    • closeup of a glass of Almond banana cinnamon smoothie on a wood table
      Almond Banana Cinnamon Smoothie
    • glass of Peach and chocolate green smoothie on a wood table with peaches in the background
      Peach and Chocolate Green Smoothie
    • closeup of two glasses of cinnamon and Coconut vanilla milkshake
      Coconut Vanilla Milkshake
    • Pumpkin smoothie in a glass on a wood table with cinnamon sticks in the background
      Pumpkin Smoothie

    Footer

    โ†‘ back to top

    About

    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Cookie Policy

    Newsletter

    • Sign Up! for emails and updates

    Contact

    • Contact

    As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

    For your information only. The statements on this website are merely opinions. Paleo Leap does not provide medical or nutritional advice, treatment, or diagnosis. Read the full disclaimer.

    Copyright ยฉ 2023 Paleo Leap