Printer icon

Cold-Weather Paleo: How to Make the Winter Work for You

Cold-weather and Paleo

Have you ever wondered why so many sugar-centric holidays fall during the coldest, crummiest time of year? Every month or so during the winter, there’s a new excuse for sugar-indulgence: Halloween to console us that the snow is coming, Thanksgiving a month later to set off the holiday feasts, Christmas and New Year’s within a week of each other, Valentine’s Day six weeks later, and Easter (roughly) six weeks after that.

Yes, some of it is thanks to the junk food industry, and some of it is because we can’t barbecue in February, but humans have been celebrating winter festivals with sugar (or honey, or whatever we could get) for a lot longer than Nestlé has been buying billboard space. To a certain extent, we’re just wired to move less and eat more (particularly more carbs) during the winter. And that’s not a coincidence – in fact, it used to be an evolutionary advantage, back in the day.

Unfortunately, today it’s not so desirable. So take a look at what causes seasonal weight patterns, why they used to be perfectly adaptive, and what you can do to gently steer your body to a place you’d rather go.

(fair warning: this is a pretty long read, but it’s a complicated topic and it’s useful to know why your body does this.)

Winter Weight Gain

During the winter, humans generally tend to eat more and exercise less. People as far apart as Turkey, the US, and rural Pakistan tend to eat more, move less, and generally put on some weight. There’s a reason why so many weightlifters and bodybuilders like to bulk in the winter and cut in the summer: it’s easier!

This pattern is visible across populations, but sometimes it takes a more extreme form as Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD), a seasonal form of depression that eases up in the summer and then comes back full force in the winter. SAD causes an increase in appetite, and specifically in carb cravings. Together with very low energy and a decreased drive to do anything, this very commonly causes overeating and weight gain. About 5-10% of people, mostly women, have SAD.

It’s pretty easy to see some of the contributing factors to this. Just to take one example, exercising is a pain in the neck in the winter; it’s harder to do anything and easier to just lie on the couch. And that’s without mentioning the temptation to stop caring because you’re already huddled under three layers of sweatshirts anyway so who’s going to notice, right? But there are also biological reasons why weight gain is easier in the winter.

For one thing, the shorter days and longer nights seem to cause various changes in mood, hormone expression, and gut flora that promote weight gain. We don’t know yet precisely what the mechanism is for this, but we have a couple ideas:

Remember how Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) is something like the extreme end of the spectrum of winter weight gain? One of the best ways to treat SAD is a combination of light therapy (artificially re-creating a summer light environment) and melatonin supplements (pushing the body’s internal clock into sync with the environment). This is another huge clue that somehow, the winter light environment is a trigger to put on a little fat.

So…winter is bad, right? It makes us depressed and fat? Well, not exactly.

Winter, Weight, and Evolution

We evolved all these weight-gain responses, because for most of our species history, fattening up in the fall and winter meant a much better chance of survival. And not just survival for us, survival for our babies.

Most obviously, cold is calorically expensive. You can’t run a furnace with no fuel, and under cold-weather conditions, your body has to turn the furnace way up. Considering that food supplies used to be unreliable during the wintertime, it made perfect sense to stock up on whatever you could get, wherever you could get it.

Especially for women, gaining weight during the winter used to be an important metabolic adaptation to pregnancy. Imagine a world without (a) central heating, (b) a guaranteed consistent food supply at all times of year, or (c) birth control. In that world, the best time for conception would be in the summer (when the woman is most fertile, because there’s the most food around), and the best time for birth would be early spring (after the hard work of the harvest is done, when there’s not a lot of heavy physical labor, but before the winter food stores run out).

If you were going to be pregnant in an age of food scarcity, the temporary fat gain in the winter and even a certain amount of desire to just curl up under the blankets instead of going out to work could be perfectly adaptive. It helped the species survive. But then we had to go and invent the electric light…

Winter Eating Behavior: How the Modern World Messed it Up

Cold temperatures, longer nights and shorter days already signal your body to hoard fat in Sleepless manpreparation for the winter. If you actually had to survive food shortage during the winter, that would be great. But for you, reading this, today, there are just two little problems:

So the “gain weight now” signal got turned up at exactly the time when we wanted it turned off. Oops. Here’s how it went so wrong:

During the winter, the days are short and the nights are long. But at least if you lived in a traditional culture, you’d probably be getting some sunlight while it lasted. Today, though, plenty of people wake up while it’s still dark, and get off work when it’s already dark again. If you work inside in a room without windows, you might not see the sun for an entire day, or even several days at a time.

If shorter days are a signal to start hoarding fat, this is a super-signal.

Ideal Anyone before 1800 in winter Cubicle warrior in winter
Light exposure in the morning: Bright/blue sunlight Bright/blue, or none:

  • Sleep longer; get up later.
  • Get up in darkness or at dawn.

 

None, or electric lights (a muddy intermediate between morning and evening)

  • Get up in darkness (no bright morning light).
Light exposure during the day Bright/blue sunlight Blue, but limited:

  • Shorter sunlight, but some light exposure during the day.

 

Electric light (intermediate between morning and evening), and possibly blue.

  • Go to work under electric lights.
  • Possibly get some blue light from using a computer.
Light exposure in the evening Red/evening light or nun. Red or none.

  • Come home and sit around a fire or go to bed.
Bright blue/ “sunlight”

  • Leave work when it’s already dark again (no warm evening light)
  • Come home and use the computer or watch TV (bright, blue, early-morning light) until bedtime.

For our hypothetical pre-electricity caveman, the winter light change wasn’t as dangerous, because it didn’t completely eliminate his window of sunlight. But in the modern world, when sun exposure is much more limited to start with, winter can completely eliminate it. And on top of that, we’re getting a bunch of pseudo-blue light in the evening!

For the modern cubicle warrior, circadian derangement will be worse (causing worse Seasonal Affective Disorder, if the person is prone to it), Vitamin D deficiency will be worse, and weight gain will probably be even more of an issue – all in an environment where the weight gain is completely unnecessary because we have a secure food supply and central heating to keep us warm. And just to top it all off, we have a much more tempting array of cheap and readily available junk food to satisfy those completely unnecessary carb cravings.

The Solution

Now we have the problem: the modern schedule magnifies a biological pattern (weight gain in winter) that used to be adaptive but isn’t healthy any longer. So how can you rearrange your lifestyle to take the stimulus in the other direction – in other words, to stop sending signals to your body that it’s time to pack on some extra fat in preparation for the wintertime?

Assuming you can’t take off work from November to March for an extended vacation in Maui, here are some practical strategies:

fish

Summing it Up

This was a pretty long read, but it’s a complicated topic! Seasonal weight gain used to be a very useful adaptation to food scarcity. The carb cravings were great, because they drove us to eat what we could, when we could get it, so we could survive when we couldn’t.

In the modern world, the physiological drive to gain weight got turned up, but the need for that weight disappeared. It’s a perfect mismatch.

All kinds of different strategies can help you deal with this:

Even if you’re not feeling the winter blues yet, looking into these things now can really help you be prepared when the time comes.