It’s not like industrially-processed oils are useless. Canola oil makes a great lubricant for machinery. And seed oils are currently being studied as alternatives to nonrenewable petroleum products for everything from fueling cars to making plastic to formulating printer ink.
But you know what soybean, canola, and other seed oils aren’t so great for? Human consumption.
Soy and canola oil, as well as less familiar products like corn, peanut, sunflower, safflower, and cottonseed oil, all fall under the dubious term of “vegetable oils.” This makes them sound a lot healthier than they really are: the word “vegetable” in the name conjures up images of broccoli and spinach, not soybeans and peanuts. But “vegetable” here just means “anything that isn’t an animal” – don’t be fooled by the marketing. (Quick note: technically, “anything not an animal” would include healthy plant fats like olive or coconut oil, but by convention, these are usually not included in the term “vegetable oil.”)
Unlike actual vegetables, “vegetable oils” are not nutrient-dense whole foods. In fact, they’re so far from whole foods that you might wonder why we even tried eating them in the first place. So here’s the story of how vegetable oils took over the US food supply, and why that’s not such a good development after all.
The Rise of Seed Oils
Americans used to cook with lard and butter: they were cheap, widely available, and tasty. But then industrially processed fats made from seeds and grains took over the food supply in the 20th century thanks to a perfect storm of advertising and economics:
- People at the beginning of the 20th century were beginning to get more and more worried about the unsanitary meat production facilities of the day; vegetable oils were easy to sell as cleaner and more “pure” because they weren’t associated with meat production.
- Seed oils are a way to turn a profit from what would otherwise be waste. Cottonseed oil would have just been thrown out if Crisco had never been invented; turning it into “food” made that trash into a gold mine. Today, subsidies for corn and soybeans make the supply of these foods much greater than the demand, and oil is one way to turn this otherwise-unprofitable surplus into “food.”
- Because they’re made from agricultural surplus, seed oils are very cheap for the consumer – just compare a bottle of canola oil to a bottle of olive oil.
- The anti-saturated-fat campaign starting in the 60s and 70s endorsed (and still endorses) seed oils as healthy alternatives to lard and butter.
By the middle of the century, “vegetable oils” were cheaper than traditional fats, widely available, and being trumpeted as “healthy choices” from every side – is it any wonder that they took off?
Here’s a chart showing the change in consumption of a few fats over time. Notice the giant spike in “shortening” (read: seed oils – this is Crisco et al.) and Margarine and the precipitous decline in butter and lard.
And here’s another one showing the consumption of just plant-based oils (without the animal fats):
Soybean oil, dominates the charts (although canola is rising rapidly). In 1909, soybean oil represented 0.006% of energy in the American diet; in 1999, it had skyrocketed to 7.38%. Here’s one more chart, showing major sources of calories between 1909 and 1999:
Notice that consumption of beef, pork, and total fat dropped off, while consumption of soy oil in particular, poultry, and “shortening” (again, think margarine and Crisco) rose. Supposedly, this ought to represent a more “heart-healthy” diet – but rates of heart disease have been climbing steadily the whole time.
(Also from that chart: consumption of grains slowly declined right up until around the start of the “obesity epidemic” in the 70s and then started rising again. That’s a correlation, and it doesn’t prove anything about cause and effect, but it’s food for thought.)
(source for all three charts plus the numbers cited in the last few paragraphs)
More Seed Oils: So What?
So why is this a problem?
It’s true that canola and soybean oil taste like nothing at all: based on culinary value alone, they never should have replaced deliciously luxurious traditional fats like lard and butter. But the consequences of seed oil’s rise to power are much worse than tasteless food.
The rise of seed oils caused a dramatic change in the nutritional composition of the American diet. Specifically, seed oils contain high amounts of a type of fat called Omega-6 PUFA. (Need a refresher on types of fat? Go here.) Traditional fats like lard and tallow contain some Omega-6 PUFA, but seed oils are a much richer source. This study looks at food available (not necessarily what was eaten, but what was in the food supply) and found that availability of Omega-6 fats skyrocketed between 1909 and 1999. The number one source: soybean oil.
So what’s so bad about that? Omega-6 fats aren’t “bad” in the abstract. In fact, we need a very small amount of them to live; that’s why they’re called “essential fatty acids.” But we don’t need nearly as much of them as we’re getting from all that canola oil.
Omega-6 fats are chemically less stable than other types of fat. They break down easily under stress – especially when they’ve been exposed to heat, light, or oxygen. Think about how we get our vegetable oil: first it sits out in a clear plastic bottle on the shelf, then it’s heated during cooking (sometimes multiple times, in the case of deep-frying). This causes a kind of damage called oxidation.
That goes double when Omega-6 fats are hanging around without their buddies the Omega-3s. Omega-3 fats. The ideal ratio of Omega-6 to Omega-3 is somewhere between 1:1 and 4:1. Between 1909 and 1999, the actual ratio of Omega-6 to Omega-3 fats in the American diet increased from 5.4:1 (that’s close to ideal) to 9.6:1 (getting into scary territory).
The double whammy of too much Omega-6 and an imbalanced O6:O3 ratio is a perfect storm for inflammatory diseases. To get a little more specific, various studies have implicated an imbalanced Omega-6 to Omega-3 ratio in…
- Cognitive decline (Alzheimer’s, dementia, etc.)
- Breast cancer
- Cardiovascular disease (although recent trials have put a damper on the initial enthusiasm, there still is a link; it’s just not as big as researchers initially thought)
- Depression and other mood disorders
- Gut problems and gut flora dysfunction
- Insulin resistance and diabetes
That’s not a list of diseases most people want to experience firsthand!
Obviously, all of these conditions have contributing factors other than Omega-6 and Omega-3 fats. But the inflammation caused by excess Omega-6 and an imbalance of Omega-6 and Omega-3s isn’t helping anything. As “health foods,” seed oils just don’t live up their promises.
Summing it Up
Seed oils (or “vegetable oils,” if you like the marketing term) just aren’t the answer to anyone’s health problems, least of all heart disease. Seed oils are a very convenient way to dispose of agricultural waste via potato chips and deep-fried Twinkies, but they’re not doing any favors for your body.
Instead of eating a bunch of industrial seed oils, maintain a healthier balance of Omega-6 and Omega-3 fats by filling your plate with fish, traditional animal fats, butter, or healthy plant fats like olive and coconut oil (not all fats made from plants are unhealthy). They’re much better for you, and the taste alone is enough to make anyone swear off canola for life.